Can we strike a Canadian compromise on John A. Macdonald’s legacy?

By Steve Paikin - Published on Aug 30, 2017
A statue of Sir John A. Macdonald in Kingston, Ont. (Lars Hagberg/CP)



Even though the Elementary Teachers’ Federation of Ontario’s resolution to strip our first prime minister’s name off the province’s schools made plenty of people furious, we should probably thank the organization for forcing a long overdue debate in this province.

Americans are neck-deep in their own version of this issue. In community after community, they’re taking down statues of Confederate soldiers and politicians, having realized that many people don’t regard those men as heroes, but rather as proponents of slavery.

And perhaps making that decision even easier is the fact that men such as Jefferson Davis, Stonewall Jackson, and Robert E. Lee were, in fact, traitors to the United States.

Sir John A. Macdonald was not a traitor himself. On the contrary: he was the single most-important political figure in creating Canada. The eminent historian and columnist Richard Gwyn has said that without Macdonald, British North America could easily have been swept into the American Civil War vortex. Instead, thanks in large part to Sir John, we became our own country and, 150 years on, are the envy of much of the world.

A man filming in The Agenda studio

Our journalism depends on you.

You can count on TVO to cover the stories others don’t—to fill the gaps in the ever-changing media landscape. But we can’t do this without you.

But of course, Macdonald’s utterances about Indigenous peoples do not stand up to 21st-century standards and values. And so, many teachers want his name scraped off the facades of elementary schools across Ontario.

Should we do this? After all, if you’re from an Indigenous community, wouldn’t the sight of Sir John offend you in the same way a statue of Robert E. Lee would offend an African-American?

By chance, last week I visited the nearly 150-year-old Beechwood Cemetery in Ottawa, the final resting place for 75,000 Canadians. Former governor-general Ramon Hnytyshyn, former prime minister Robert Borden, and former federal NDP leader and Saskatchewan premier Tommy Douglas are all buried there.

So is someone you’ve probably never heard of: Nicholas Flood Davin, a lawyer, journalist, member of parliament, and man of letters, originally from Ireland. And that’s mostly what you’ll find out about Davin if you read his headstone.

However, there’s a new plaque beside Davin’s gravesite that adds some greater context to his life. The plaque points out that at the request of Prime Minister John A. Macdonald, Davin wrote a report called “Industrial Schools for Indians and Half-Breeds.” We go on to learn that Davin was an architect of the residential school system, which aimed to remove “the influence of the wigwam” from Indigenous children. The plaque concludes by quoting the Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s view that the policy was tantamount to cultural genocide.

a plaque

As I read the headstone, then the modern plaque in front of it, I began to wonder whether this wasn’t an appropriate Canadian compromise for other figures from our history whose views were abhorrent by modern standards.

So I wonder: rather than expunging our history of yesterday’s leaders, perhaps we should do what they’ve done at the Beechwood Cemetery. Perhaps we should start erecting a lot more plaques, acknowledging the contribution of the historic figure in question but also explaining the darker side of their legacy.

We really do need to figure this out because it won’t end with Sir John, whose name and face appear on statues, roads, and buildings across the country, not to mention on the $10 bill. Sir Wilfrid Laurier’s face is on the $5 bill, and his name appears on an Ontario university, a prominent Ottawa hotel, and elsewhere. He was also the prime minister who sent the Chinese “head tax” skyrocketing.

The Komagata Maru incident, in which immigrants from India were denied entry into Canada, took place on Borden’s watch. Should we take him off the $100 bill? German-Canadians, Italian-Canadians, and especially Japanese-Canadians were interned in World War II, during William Lyon Mackenzie King’s tenure. Should we take him off our $50 bill?

This may be one of those wonderful teachable moments in our history: we don’t have to bury the past, because that would actually hinder our ability to learn from it.

Maybe we should start putting up some plaques. Or even better, maybe we should start naming more schools after the many Indigenous figures who helped shape this country, too many of whom have been forgotten in our history.

Clarification: This post originally stated that Japanese-Canadians were held in "prison camps." The facilities can be more accurately described as "internment camps." [Visit the Canadian Encyclopedia for more information.]

Thinking of your experience with, how likely are you to recommend to a friend or colleague?
Not at all Likely
Extremely Likely

Most recent on TVO