image TVO Parents
Forgot Password? Sign Up

Your Agenda

SERVICE NOTICE: The Your Agenda discussion boards are now locked and you will no longer be able to post new comments. Existing posts will still be available as 'read only'. If you wish to discuss the Agenda, please do so on the Inside Agenda Blog. If you want to join a guided discussion about other TVO content, please join our new discussion area here.
Search | See all topics for this forum | Your Agenda Home | Jump to:
Sign in to comment
 Forget password?
Don't have an account?
Forum: Talk About Everything Else
Topic: Home grown terror

The genesis of home grown terror and human bombs.

 

Humanizing suicide bombers is not a task many would entertain or applaud, given the proof of their subjects’ brutal agency. However, that is the territory explored by British writer-director, Peter Kosminsky, in his two-part drama, Britz. The series airs on TVO Sunday, February 3 at 9 PM, part two on Sunday, February 10 at 9 PM.

 

Equally important to Ontarians, as to Britons is the central question that drove the creator of this fictionalized story:

 

“How was it that a group of second-generation British Muslims, born here, raised here, educated in British schools, steeped in British culture, could have become so angry, feel themselves so powerless and disenfranchised, that they would strap explosives to their bodies and set out to kill and maim their fellow British citizens.”

 

A brother and sister in a contemporary Muslim family choose very different paths in dealing with the anti-terror crackdown in the aftermath of the July 2005 subway bombings in London. Here in Ontario a group of Muslim men and youths are being held on charges related to recruiting, training and weapons possession allegedly connected to a terror plot against political and media targets.

 

To sample some of the Britz drama and hear what other writers are saying about the roots and reasoning behind homegrown terror and human bombs, go to our Britz microsite. For more in Kosminsky’s own words on this very difficult dramatization, see The Telegraph magazine.

 

The chief protagonist in Britz, Nasima Wahid, is a politically savvy, socially active young medical student in Britain. She comes to face a choice most of us would consider unthinkable. On the Agenda, Friday, February 1, Steve Paikin interviews a panel of contemporary Canadian Muslim women. Among them is Safiyyah Ally, a doctoral student in political science at U of T. In an upcoming post on tvo.org/Britz, she explores the questions that spring from Britz and the conditions instilled to contend with terror in Britain and Canada: What obligation do Muslims have towards their country? Does that obligation trump their commitment to their faith and their fellow-believers? Are the two separate sets of commitments compatible?

 

And there are more questions we as a society need to address: Have western governments gone overboard in their zeal to detect and stifle the devastation of terror attacks? Are the civil liberties of the few expendable for the benefit of the rest of a society? Have holy words been hijacked by deliberate misinterpretations? What is the role of Muslim and non-Muslim leadership in certifying our physical security?

Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Started on 22 Jan 08 at 2:20 PM 
Last edit: 29 Jan 08 at 1:44 PM

by David H

Previous Topic See All Topics  Next Topic
Replies
home grown terror

British youth are not strapping explosives to themselves because they are disenfranchised. This is a false assumption. I would recommend the book "The Islamist" to anyone who wants an in-depth look at this phenomenon. It is written by a man who is a British muslim and has been in and out of many of these groups. These organizations are run by people who are nothing more than thugs in an heirarchy of organized crime. Religion is simply an excuse to perpetrate their crimes. Aside from the silence of the Muslim community in Britain, much of what has taken place is the fault of the British Governement. They have let this foment under their noses and have been cowed by fear of offending minorities. This is political correctness taken to a sick extreme. There was no reason for these dangerous groups to think that they couldn't get away with theft, murder, extortion, and vile hate speech. The British government gave them the red carpet. This should serve as a lesson to other Western governemnts to take action before this sick cult takes hold here.




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 22 Jan 08 at 2:49 PM
by leslie finer
home grown terror

<>

Leslie, I suppose the assumption was only a starting point for the creators of Britz. We want to make some sense of horrifying realities and we apply justifications that satisfy our need to see a logic. However the truth is not always what it might appear. Irshad Manji talks about her discovery of that very truth in the second of our videos on the Britz website. 





Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 22 Jan 08 at 5:33 PM
Last edit: 24 Jan 08 at 4:12 PM

by David H
home grown terror
I think that the justifications we apply to terrorism are based on our Western outlook.  Most of us have no other means to try and understand this phenomena other than from the norms, feelings, and values of Western society. That is why we give the benefit of the doubt to suicide bombers by believing that we have done something wrong - that we somehow deserve this. There is a time for talk, undersanding, and reconciliation with people who are willing partners. Weather we missed that boat or weather we never had a willing partner may not be important. Canada needs to have serious plans in place for preventing terrorism and dealing harshly with terrorists and their accomplices. Unfortunately, Irshad Manji is a voice of reason, intelligence and insight that is hard to find in the Muslim community. She in fact is despised by many Muslims because of her views and lifestyle. I wonder how long ago that snippet of Tarek Fatah was taken. Pehaps it was a while ago as he had been threatened by extremeists in the Muslim community and left his position with the Muslim Canadian Congress.


Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 22 Jan 08 at 7:23 PM
by leslie finer
RE: home grown terror




leslie finer said: I wonder how long ago that snippet of Tarek Fatah was taken. Pehaps it was a while ago as he had been threatened by extremeists in the Muslim community and left his position with the Muslim Canadian Congress.

 

You're right, it is an archival clip from a segment on Studio 2 in a Going Global special a couple of years back. You're also right that Fatah stepped down from the leadership of the MCC. But he's still listed on their web page as its founder, and here he's described as an "ordinary member" of the organization.





Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 23 Jan 08 at 10:02 AM
Last edit: 24 Jan 08 at 3:59 PM

by David H
suicide bombers
Obviously the Muslim religion is a toxic environment !


Alert Administrator
markb Posted on 23 Jan 08 at 2:52 PM
by markb
RE: suicide bombers




markb said: Obviously the Muslim religion is a toxic environment !

Would you ascribe poisonous attributes to only this one among all religions? Is it the faith system itself or particular personages in their practice of it with whom you find fault?





Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 24 Jan 08 at 4:10 PM
Last edit: 24 Jan 08 at 4:11 PM

by David H
Home grwon terror

I think the sad reality is that muslims have been snoring their heads off for hundreds of years. They still want to live at the time of the prophet, which is a very unique time of history. The prophet had a task from GOD to deliver a message; he faught the people, mainly his own people, because they were preventing him from delivering the message and from practicing the teachings of the message. This situation was what he called the minor JEHAD and it is over. Now the message has been delivered. Freedom of religion is all over the place. The time now is for the major JEHAD, which is fighting your self and your ego (pride) and try to be humble and helpful. The message of the prophet Mohammad (PBUH) is a restoration of the original message of Abraham (PBUH). To worship GOD (the only GOD) and to be good to yourself and others; it is really that simple and it is in all the Abrahamic messages. Whatever you dress or whether you shave or grow any hair is up to your intellegence; GOD does not want us to be robots and follow a strict scheme of appearances. He gave us intellegence as a gift to use it. So, military action can hardly be justified anywhere any time in the name of GOD as long as freedom of religion is granted that appears to be all over, especially in the civilized west. Killing people is a major crime, whether suicide or otherwise.

Mohammad Elmoselhi




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 01 Feb 08 at 10:11 PM
Last edit: 01 Feb 08 at 10:17 PM

by Moh
Muslim Exremist Culture

( David H ): “How was it that a group of second-generation British Muslims, born here, raised here, educated in British schools, steeped in British culture, could have become so angry..........

" steeped in British culture " is where we make the fundamental mistake concerning such immigrants. They were most diligently raised in a Muslim family and brought up to believe in Islamic fundamentalism. Thus this whole issue of terrorists being British ( or any other western ) citizens and therefore home grown is to be abysmally naive about the hold traditional culture has on immigrant families. In addition they are indoctrinated by extremists funded by oil cash emanating from the Middle East, officially to raise and support Mosques. Guess what happens when nobody is looking.

Good post Leslie Finer.




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 01 Feb 08 at 11:46 PM
by DieterH
Home grown terror
I watched with interest the first part of the Drama 'Britz'and was struck by the fact that it seems that this generation of British born Muslims are angry but for what reason I cannot ascertain, I know that there are some people and I stress some people that are racist in this society but I also must add that this is a two way street,  since Islam is a religion and not a race some of this anger is not justified or at least it should not be used as the root cause for the anger, we see the anger that manifests itself in ways that is beyond reasonable such as the Danish cartoons or the British teacher that was jailed because she allowed her class to name a teddy bear Mohammed. in the West it has always been that political satire or cartoon if you wish have been society's way of making a point, the recipient may not like it but that is the western culture, therefore visitors to a western nation should be made to understand that it not intended to be insulting but more to make a point, just as if I, visiting a Muslim country I would respect their ways and do my best to abide by their laws and culture, I would not dream of saying to them 'your way is wrong' so I think the visitors to our country should relax more not be so touchy and sensitive that is if they wish to continue to live in the West and to be accepted.


Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 03 Feb 08 at 11:44 PM
by scodio
More Excellent British Programming on Terrorism

The BBC also produced an excellent docu-drama exploring the fallout :) from the detonation of a "dirty bomb" in London.  It aired once, several months before the July 7 attacks.  The main BBC page for "Dirty War" is:

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/dirty_war/default.stm

 

Interestingly, it has been released on DVD in the US, but not in the UK.. See:

http://www.amazon.com/Dirty-War-Gavin-Abbott/dp/B0007R4SXQ

 Also see:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZlGuLfyWOY

 

More cheerful stuff:

For those of you who want to look back at the Cold War-era nuclear films: Threads: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AfzGyJxViEc 

When the Wind Blows:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdguWMF1abU&feature=related

 

Nuclear War; A Guide to Armageddon:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1vdzyqQIEAI&feature=related

 are all on YouTube.

 

and for those chilling Brit public information films:

http://www.nationalarchives.gov.uk/films/1964to1979/filmpage_casualties.htm

and

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXx5Y2Fr2bk

 




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 04 Feb 08 at 12:02 AM
by Fatalist93
humanitydoesnotexist@hotmail.com

My point to the whole of society  is to investitgate why  one needs a God a religion and a country .

This no  one is going to do as all we become jobless.  One needs evilness

 to be employed.

 

One needs sick people to be employed.

 

read www.whatiscivilization.com 

 




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 04 Feb 08 at 9:57 AM
by god_is_love_and_truth
RE: humanitydoesnotexist@hotmail.com



god_is_love_and_truth said:

My point to the whole of society is to investigate why one needs a God a religion and a country .

This no one is going to do as all we become jobless. One needs evilness

to be employed.

 

One needs sick people to be employed.

Yes, they do say that the Devil finds work for idle hands though.   Wink




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 04 Feb 08 at 10:25 AM
by Wisdom of the aged
Support of wars against Islam begets retaliation

Dear Leslie et al;-

It's the ME blood feud Leslie! 

When we allow our governments to participate in the blood feud that spread out from the unholy land in the Middle East and with the help of the two Bushes has escalated into a global war of terror, and when we support this insane war against innocent Islamic nations by sending our armies and fantastic military machines to destroy them, then surely they or their kin will try to retaliate directly against us because we have unwittingly and foolishly been made their mortal enemies.

Western nations have turned predator:  

There is no moral or legal argument that we can use to defend ourselves once we have attacked them and killed their families, destroyed their villages, towns, and cities from the air and the ground, and then tried to impose our political will on them. Then we have the arrogance to call it liberation, democratization, advancement of human rights, and the rest of the Neocon  and Zionist propaganda as we pile up their bodies, poison their lands with DU and landmines, take control of their resources, and impose our will on the survivors because we claim that we know better than they do about what is good for them and how they should be living. (Please note heavy use of sarcasm here!)

Canada was duped into helping Washington and Tel Aviv 

Canada, because of its unholy alliance with Washington and Tel Aviv, has been dragged into their spreading blood feud, and those who support the Necon Zionist wars can no longer claim to be innocent civilians. If we use the same arguments that the Neocon and Zionist extremists use against those who harbour, fund, aid, and abet what they call terrorists, and we likewise fund and support western forces that strike at Islamic villages, towns, and cities, then we are as directly responsible as we hold supporters like the Taliban. No matter what Harper and his con men try to tell you, the Islamic people who are fighting back against western colonization of Islamic homelands are not doing it to destroy our wonderful values, so long as we don't impose those values on them.

We must stop this insane war now...

The west is clearly at fault for attacking and destroying Islamic countries and colonize them. The Islamic people have not been able to tell their story here because the media is controlled largely by those very powerful groups that want us to fight on their side. We know it is wrong and it is up to us, the common little people to tell our enslaved government to get out of an immoral and illegal war.

 

Islamic

leslie finer said: I think that the justifications we apply to terrorism are based on our Western outlook. Most of us have no other means to try and understand this phenomena other than from the norms, feelings, and values of Western society. That is why we give the benefit of the doubt to suicide bombers by believing that we have done something wrong - that we somehow deserve this. There is a time for talk, undersanding, and reconciliation with people who are willing partners. Weather we missed that boat or weather we never had a willing partner may not be important. Canada needs to have serious plans in place for preventing terrorism and dealing harshly with terrorists and their accomplices. Unfortunately, Irshad Manji is a voice of reason, intelligence and insight that is hard to find in the Muslim community. She in fact is despised by many Muslims because of her views and lifestyle. I wonder how long ago that snippet of Tarek Fatah was taken. Pehaps it was a while ago as he had been threatened by extremeists in the Muslim community and left his position with the Muslim Canadian Congress.




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 04 Feb 08 at 8:55 PM
by Steelcity Steve
Vicious advice from an Imam.

Apparently, the Qran states explicitly that no Moslem should take up arms against a state that has welcomed him and given him asylum; thus, a Moslem  who has been granted immigrant status, and later citizenship in the U.K. is forbidden to engage in acts of terror there.

Recently an Imam - sorry that I cannot identify him - was quoted as stating that this provision of the Qran does NOT apply to the children or grandchildren of original immigrants.  Mom and dad are not to self-destruct in London underground trains, taking dozens of innocents with them, but the kids are free to engage in such terrorist acts.

Islam, we are told is "a religion of peace".  

We need to have someone remind this particular Imam of that fact. 




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 05 Feb 08 at 11:26 AM
by Wisdom of the aged
Home Grown Terror

We ignore the fact that it is never the Imams or other leaders of Islamic fundamentalist factions who commit suicide bombings themselves, but encourage the credulous and naive fanatics to perform this part of jihad. Maybe they are not sure what Allah would say to them when they arrive in heaven - he may decide to send them in the other direction !

Such degraded acts are viewed with incomprehension by the West, thus stain all of Islam.




Alert Administrator
No Avatar Uploaded Posted on 05 Feb 08 at 12:29 PM
by DieterH
Previous Thread See All Topics  Next Thread
  1  2  3  Next Page > >>
Search | See all topics for this forum | Your Agenda Home | Jump to:
SNAM